I bought a scooter from an Italian dealer and shipped it to Tortola and it was
definitely cheaper than buying it from the dealer in St. Maarten.
In fact, I paid about the same amount for my new 2008, LX125 (including shipping from St. Maarten) with
no accessories as I did for a new, 2009 LX125 with fuel injection plus a lot of accessories (installed by the dealer), several spare parts and including shipping costs from Italy!
However, as Eric mentioned, you'd not have a U.S. spec scooter and that would likely cause some problems at customs for you. For me, it was no problem as we don't have any requirements to worry about here.
