Ginch wrote:
MJRally wrote:
Pinasco idle timing was listed at 24*BTDC. That put me wide open at 16*. It was too much and I holed my piston. You may want to consider going conservative and making it so at WOT, you dont go below 17.
Sorry for butting in, but isn't piston holing generally associated with high timing numbers? Like when you fit a kit, but leave the static timing at 23? You hear about it regularly. The low numbers are often described as safer, hence why all the variable timing systems retard as the revs get higher. So by using 17 as your low point instead of 16, you are actually advancing the timing right across the rev range aren't you?
Hopefully Patrick or one of the more knowledgeable two stroke experts will chime in to clarify but let me see if I can explain how I think of it. Fuel burns at a certain rate. If you ignite too early (25*+) the piston is going headfirst into an explosion at the wrong time and the opposing blast is what does damage. So in that instance lowering the numbers (retarding the ignition will help).
If you ignite too late, fuel can only burn so fast and youre not giving it a chance since the piston is really moving so youre going to build up a ton of heat/ loss of power. Too much heat can cause detonation which can ignite carbon on the head/ Cause the fuel to burn uncontrolled (so you use higher octane gas to stabilize the burn) and lean out the mixture.
So you find the Goldilocks setting which is designed for the kit and works with the head profile. Malossi says thats 18*BTDC. Polini 16* Piaggio going the conservative route left huge squish gaps in the head and said 24-18* depending on the model engine. The huge squish isn't the best for power, but it is for reliability and emissions. So, Hot Rod Al and other performance makers skim heads, change the head shape and bring the squish down to get the best power/Best burn shape but at the sake of reliability. Black magic stuff!
So what caused my Rally piston to hole? Could be a fleck of carbon that ignited? Could it have been a weak piston? Cheap gas? Timing too retarded 16* which caused things to heat up? I sadly dont know. What I do know is that I've adjusted my flytech to stop at 17* WOT, left everything else the same and its never happened since.