Modern Vespa

None.
Primo Gucci Leather roll bags, plastic milk crates, Piaggio top cases, Vespa top cases, Shads, Givis, plywood boxes - they all spoil the otherwise sleek lines of a scooter, IMHO.

Refused them on my Forza and Burgman....but had to use them on my smaller scooters...to the detriment of their appearance.







They are useful - and can be a nice safety feature if you buy one with running & brake lights in them.....but they're ugly.
And apparently - a percentage of people buy a scooter rather than a motorcycle to haul stuff around. (I suspect it has more to do with fear of shifting)

O.S.

taste is such a subjective matter in that one can have none at all.

nope

I like.
Big.
Butts and I cannot lie.
You other riders can't deny.
When a scooter rolls in
With an itty bitty waist
And a voluminous top case
Your shock's SPRUNG.
Wanna pull up tough
Cuz you notice that case was stuffed
Deep and the Wasp is wearing
I'm hooked and I can't stop staring...

Yeah, baby.
...Just a glove box, pet carrier, and a backpack?
Only if I'm bringing it home from the dealership.

Kudos to him. It's not an easy thing to admit to being wrong or fallible, especially in a public forum. It's a good step. It's an even better one if one not only owns their mistakes, but learns from them.

Bailed myself out with a $15 tap tonight. That was after realizing I danged up an odd thread when using a hammer and drift while distracted. Now I know how to fix it, have the tool to fix it and the reminder to be more attentive when driving fork legs out of a steering stem.

As for topcases, I put one on my little bike (Spade 150) and went for a 30L GIVI. Can't lie, makes the bikes butt look 'uge. I need to use it more and see if I can reconcile its utility with its impact on the bike's appearance.

nope

It is known.

My Helix clone has a huge box and it serves at least one good purpose. My helmet fits in it. My two motorcycles have locking helmet hooks so they are almost as easy in that regard. I bought saddlebags that go over the seat and clip on to the bike for Americade. They worked like a charm. I popped them off and carried them into the hotel like suitcases. Put them back on to go home and ran the bike without them when riding up there.

I have one sitting in the garage for the new scoot. It will go on eventually.

I'm mostly agnostic on the aesthetics of topcases, although some are nicer than others. For the time being, I'm not putting one on my new ride, but simply using the seat bag I used on Melody, which is easy to add, remove, and hand-carry.

In seriousness: to each their own.

In shenanigans... It could be worse. It could be a footlocker on a metropolitan.
I wish this was a picture I pulled from the internet. I took this picture back in 2015. I don't even want to THINK about how much that cantilevered the front wheel.

I don't know about you guys - but when I'm riding I can't see my top-box, so I don't GAF. It does become very useful when I'm not riding, and filling it with groceries or better - beer.

I'm in the function over form camp. Practicality beats Preening.

Two of the Vespas I bought used came with color matching factory top boxes and the first thing I did when I got them home was take off the top box. I don't like the look, if I need that much carrying capacity I'll take my car.

If I opened the garage door and picked which bike to ride based solely on sexiness, the Vespa would never get taken out. It ranks second out of six. Yet I ride it much more frequently than the best looking bike. Aesthetics aren't everything. Love my top case.

I reluctantly put a top case on my first Vespa, because the pet carrier won't hold a modular helmet (or even a 3/4 helmet). However on the 2020 GTS HPE... yeah, the pet carrier won't hold a helmet, either.

I guess I've grown accustomed to the look with the top case - when I take it off (to strap something that wouldn't fit in the case back there), the bike looks nekkid. I added a color match panel to the Givi 37L top case, and it just looks like it belongs.

Beauty is in the eye of... well, you know. I don't "dress my bike up" for anyone but me.

I agree with the OP and greasy. Some people have no (read: bad) taste, and my scooter looks much better without a top case.

I toyed with attaching a top case on the pillion seat to use it as a backrest. I liked the look more, but never followed through. I have a problem.

I used to take the screen and top box off the LX regularly. It seemed to fool the ridiculously large primordial "you need a new scooter" part of my brain.
And then the "You need something more practical" part started to tingle.
Very satisfying knowing I'm smarterer than cave man me.

nope

This one has a non-detachable topcase. And hell yeah, this one feels injured without it.

I have a love/hate relationship with mine, I hate the look but it serves so many purposes. Storage ang great to carry my DJ vinyl. When I win lotto I'll buy a Vespa without one😁

Same with a screen.

Useful but not pretty

I like "naked" bikes of all sorts.

To the extent, that so far I've refused to use any fixed sidebags or topcases in by bikes - the definition of fixed includes metal gadgets to fix removable bags and boxes.

Yet, when I had my Vespa, I did opt for a topbox Scoot is a practical vehicle, right...? A confession: I thougth I'd use Vespa more for my commuting. In the end mostly preferred a car, a fact that the lazy, comfort-seeking me should have known, in the Northern climate.

And of course, if would ride a GS Bimmer, it would kind of have to include all the walk-in-closet -thingies, because...well, because. I won't, but I know it would.

No discerning Mod would ever install one but they are okay if you work for Uber Eats.

I agree! They're so ugly! I also didn't buy one for my scooter and my plan is to take stuff in brown-leather saddlebags. Sadly there are none of those in my city, I probably will have do sew them myself.

I also am not a fan of top cases. I have an OEM on that I take on and off regularly. Always have it on when riding two up. Mrs. CLE is more comfortable with the back rest. When by my self, I pop the case off and just go with the rack. No real reason other than I like the look.

Chris from CLE

"Is it safe to wear a backpack 🎒 on
a motorcycle?".........makes for interesting reading.
However --- putting one on a Child who is riding pillion isn't addressed.
O.S.

Function over form ....

My friend Ivan told me that whenever he went to a school dance in Moscow he'd always look around for the girl who could carry the most firewood.

O.S.

Forza, Burgman, Kymco? The problem is your putting lipstick on a pig. Modern Vespa riders don't have that problem.

Just sayin'

After having two Vespas without top cases, I couldn't wait to get one for my new Sei Giorni. I love the option of extra storage if you need it, and who cares what others think, it works for me. 😀

Nothing screams scooter like a top box. I don't like the look and I think it'll keep the haters guessing. Just like the BBK vs bigger bike argument, if I can't carry it on the floorboard and backpack, I drive a bigger vehicle.

That's Great, because my wife said that I couldn't get a Motorcycle, but she's ok if I get a Scooter 🛵 😂

Scooters are so sexy without a top box!

You too, eh?

'Course, I insisted that whatever scoot I got had to be highway-capable, thus came Melody (and, subsequently, Thelonica, mere days ago). I see you just got a Sei Giorni, so same-same but different.

Most but not all.

With the Forza and Burgman - I agree that a top case is superfluous. They have enough under seat storage to accommodate full face helmets and plenty of stuff at other times.

For smaller scoots, it does become a necessary item for many. When I was commuting on my GTS everyday, I needed room for my laptop, lunch and non-riding shoes while in the office. For touring, the top case is a great place for all the miscellaneous stuff I might need.

I can't store my modular helmet under the seat, so the top case serves as secure and weatherproof storage when off the bike.

Personally, I think the red BV200 pictured above looks awesome with top and side cases.

The top case is so useful that I don't care how it looks.

Same as a scooter "skirt" in cold weather.

Helmets, too, for that matter.

A few years ago I bought an identical b125 complete with topbox and side panniers in the same colour . At a rally a friend voiced his opinion that the luggage made it look ugly . " Yes " I replied " maybe it does , but have you any idea just how much beer I can carry ? " He slunk away , deflated .

Yeah. + 1

O.S.

Agreed - that is a nice unit!
O.S.

I like the airflow with a box, a slight breeze from behind...
The underseat storage is fine for keeping my lunch warm, but not for frozen foods
Backpacks are fun, having to surrender it at customer service when shopping...
I like form, but function wins

Sacrilege!

I'm function over form. The beauty of having enough space to transport the stuff I frequently carry, plus a dry, safe space for my helmet balances out with the clean, simple look of an unadorned scooter.