The Ratto Conclusion:
If you made it this far...Hopefully this thread inspires anyone that has a scooter with some dents or scratches. I tried to keep it real with my wins and fails. Others might glean from that experience and encourage a project that they have sitting, waiting for some love.
I wouldn't recommend signing up for an online salvage auction expecting a road worthy Vespa. That is a bag of worms for potential problems. There is a good chance it is uneconomically repairable, at the end of the day it's wiser to just purchase a new or newer Vespa in excellent condition. Set a budget and stick to it, if it doesn't look feasible then take a pass on that machine. You can get upside down money-wise. The parts and consumables add up fast.
For dent repair, spot painting, or just reviving an older scooter, it's not a bad way to go if you are not too picky and overly critical with your repair abilities. You will save all of those labor costs $$$ if you have the time, space, willingness and some basic tools to march through the process. The preparation work will vary concerning the extent of the damage.
Most hurdles can be overcome with some "thinking outside of the box". You don't have to purchase specialty tools every step of the way. There's usually a reasonable substitute to get you over that hurdle. Let's face it, if you're a perfectionist your best bet is to take it to a body shop or purchase a new scooter. A good plan executed today is better than an excellent plan started maybe next year…
The single stage acrylic urethane paint system was definitely worth it for my situation. Looking back on it, as a novice spray painter, I'd just stop at that stage and forego the optional clear coat stage. I caused myself more work by having to redo that portion. In the end the results looked about the same. Although, having now experienced that, I'll be better at it should another project arise.
There is no substitute for experience, and you only get that by doing it. Unless you are a natural, all of the good, intended advice and video watching will only take you so far. One still has to actually do the task. I can see why some folks just pound out the dents, spray on some rattle can flat color and slap on a few stickers!
You learn just enough to be dangerous! For the record, my lifelong friend and a 35-year autobody work veteran did give me some long-distance advice. His biggest encouragement was "Good on you for diving in, it's not as easy as it looks". There certainly is a feeling of accomplishment knowing that you gave it your best. We plan to keep this scooter for a long time and ride the wheels off of it. The branded title with low resale value was a nonissue. This was essentially a "new-wrecked" scooter that now lives to ride another day.
Good luck with your project!