Bob Copeland wrote:
Jess,
Sorry for the delayed response. Personal stake in transgender involvement in women's sports. Fair question.
When I grew up, I participated in organized sports at school from the 5th grade through the 12th grade. Ladies had nothing. I benefited a great deal learning to be self confident, competitive, and mentally tough by caring on even when losing. These experiences severed me well at work in my adult life.
I was an advocate and pleased when Title 9 was passed in 1972 giving ladies teams to play on an scholarships for college - learn the same stuff I benefited from.
Perhaps not that significant - but, I believe the trans involvement detracts from Title 9. I also maintain that nontrans men should not play in women's sports. From what I understand, there is no legal issue in men or women playing in each others sports at any level.
So, if women's swimming was flooded with men, the guys would take the Gold, Silver and Bronze positions relegating women to 4th, 5th and lower finishes.
I am part of the past, call me old fashioned. I do believe athletically men and women are different.
Bob Copeland
I've been watching the replies for the past week. I too come from an athletic background. I started competing/racing in cross country running back in the early 80's. I was in the 3rd grade. Our little rural elementary school happened to be fortunate enough to have a cross country team. We had both a girls and a boys team. I continued in junior high with xc. I also joined a private track club. And everyone on the track team were there to compete. The boys gave 100%, the girls gave 100%. My sister was also in the same track club. She raced the 800 meters and threw discus and shot put. She also competed in the heptathon. She made it to nationals on the girls relay team. I raced 1500 meter, 3000, meter, and high jump.
Once in highshool i continued to race xc (5000 meters) track and field (1500m, 3k, and high jump). My sister raced the 800 meter, discus, and was on the swim team. She went to state in both swimming and discus.
A continued racing xc in college. My sister quit with the organized sports and switched to sk8 boarding.
I continued racking after college. I eventually joined a running club and raced on their xc team. I also did LOTS and LOTS of road races…10k, 15k, half marathons, and marathons.
I quit competitively running when i was around 35 years old (nagging calf muscle issue). I now race bicycles at local races. I also go to the gym about 12 hours a week to work on both cardio and weights.
My niece also raced track and cross country. So did my best friend's daughter.
I have literally meet, raced against, or rubbed shoulders with thousands of other competitive athletes (girls, boys, men, women) over the past 40+ years. I have had multiple coaches coach me. I've had both female and male coaches. I'm also friends with multiple coaches whose job WAS to coach other runners. As in the runners would pay the coach $$$$.
I have been, and i have been around highly competitive athletes my whole life (starting at about 8 years to 48 years old…and counting). Being I have seen women's sports get bigger, stronger, more competitive, and better established throughout the years. I have personally know/known countless female runners and cyclists. Of all those competitive girls/women, i have never, ever meet one who would be ok with directly competing against man in a woman's event…like ever. I can say with certainty that the general public has absolutely no idea what competitive men and women sacrifice to hone their ability.
-Going to bed early,
-waking up early.
-track workouts might be at 6am.
-track workouts might be at 9pm.
-skipping deserts
-skip hanging out on a fri/sat night with friends.
-eating LOTS of chicken and rice.
-passing on comfort foods.
-your saturday or sunday mornings revolve around a long 16~20mile run.
-you spend $1000's a year on shoes and running clothes because you quickly wear them out.
-You focus mentally monday through friday in order to be prepared to race on saturday.
-ect, ect, ect.
Both competitively girls, boys, men, and women eat, think, and breathe this way. The general public who trots a 5k fun run on a sunday morning will never understand this.
I believe that ALL people from all walks of life, red, yellow, black, and white, trans, Paralympics, special olympics should be able to compete…BUT compete in their own assigned gender. I'm confident that every single competitive female athlete (runner, swimmer, cyclist) that i've ever meet would be absolutely livid to have a dude in their racing class. And why is that? Well, because men are just built stronger and faster. I don't know what science says different, nor have i ever bother to read that science, but if one decides to look at both the men's and women's times and records, it will undoubtedly put to rest who is physically stronger. Same thing for the records in junior high, highschool, college.
Yes i do know a couple transgender (guys switching over to girls) folks. Just two that i know of personally. One was on my XC team. She (he) fast for a guy, but she (he) was faster than all the other woman that were her (his) age. No one had anything against her whatsoever. No one hated, gave grief, cracked jokes, be mean, ect to her. She was a bit older, so not quite as competitive. It never bothered or fazed me when i would talk with her. There's also another trans at the gym i go to. We're both on a first name basis. We both chat ever now and then, talk about our weekends or jobs. I have absolutely no beef with her. I enjoy seeing her show up to the gym just as much as any other person who walks through the front door. I will say this about here though…even though we have a similar build (body), she can out bench press me and outdo me on the lat pull down machine…just sayin.
Woman's sports have had to scratch and claw itself to where it is now. To have a trans athlete compete in a girls/woman class is really doing a disservice to the young women. I still follow local highschool xc and track. Earlier this year a (local to me in oregon) sophomore dude won first at the state championship in the woman's 200 meter hurdles. I felt sooo bad far all of those young woman who worked so hard to get to state, only to get kicked in the crotch like that. It completely negates everything both girls and women have worked and trained so hard for. I've also been to multiple professional track meets to watch olympians compete. I'm one of those guys who like to watch the women race to watch them compete!…not to ogle or leer at what they're wearing. Probably my favorite all time race discipline to watch is the woman's 1500 meters. Those gals are soooo dang competitive! Elbows being thrown, fists making contact, shoulder checks, pushing, shoving, blocking, ect. Those gals are tuff to say the least!
I don't have any ill will towards a trans athlete. But being a competitive athlete myself, there's no question a trans will have a physical advantage.
So what's the answer? I don't have one, and even if i did i most likely wouldn't ever bring it up in a general conversation with someone who has never been a competitive athlete. I will say this, since women had to work so hard to get recognized and have their own racing class, maybe the trans need to do the same? Over in Portland (which is a very liberal city), there's always bicycle races happening. What the bicycle groups came up with was to separate the classes out…MEN, WOMAN, TRANS. The trans get to race with the men, but are scored separately. As far as i know there's no complaints from either side.
Like i said a few times before, the general public who hasn't ever been competitive will have no idea of how important woman's sports are and how detrimental trans competing are to the woman. So i wouldn't expect them to understand or think that it's a big deal.
FYI, i was at a cross country running meet this morning. LOTS of super fast girls and guys there!
I'm not looking to argue or debate, just to bring to light how important women athletics are!