UTC

Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
 
Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
Follow-up question, please. What about the intake port opening? Is it the same (or thereabouts) cross sectional area a.k.a. the same?
Not the same. The short ends up about 10% smaller. But 10% smaller than huge is not exactly a problem.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Jack221 wrote:
Not the same. The short ends up about 10% smaller. But 10% smaller than huge is not exactly a problem.
Thanks Jack221! 10% I can work around, by means of grinding, drilling and welding. πŸ‘πŸ»
⚠️ Last edited by Rikko on UTC; edited 1 time
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Jack221 wrote:
...The 28mm carb is really small for a 250 single. 34mm to 39mm is more acceptable.
Another follow-up. 😁 When you say small, is it 'do not even try' small, or it can work but with 'benefit' of reduced peak power?
Didn't show this before, "il cheapettone" 28 PWK clone, together with entire jet range.
Not pictured is accompanying sponge filter and some singlefold.
Totals to about €75.
Didn't show this before, "il cheapettone" 28 PWK clone, together with entire jet range. Not pictured is accompanying sponge filter and some singlefold. Totals to about €75.
@chandlerman avatar
UTC

Innovator
63 GL, 62 VBB, 05 Stella, 66 Smallstate, 66 Lammy S3, 63 Lammy S3 Riverside
Joined: UTC
Posts: 13341
Location: Nashville

400 Days Since Last Explosion
 
Innovator
@chandlerman avatar
63 GL, 62 VBB, 05 Stella, 66 Smallstate, 66 Lammy S3, 63 Lammy S3 Riverside
Joined: UTC
Posts: 13341
Location: Nashville

400 Days Since Last Explosion
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
Another follow-up. 😁 When you say small, is it 'do not even try' small, or it can work but with 'benefit' of reduced peak power?
It's "can work with reduced power." You are going to want a 30 or 32mm PWK, maybe a 34, depending on how high it revs.

The tradeoff is that as you go bigger for peak power, it'll be harder to get off idle to 3/8 throttle dialed in. And don't forget that you'll probably need a larger intake manifold to match the carb size.
UTC

Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
 
Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
Another follow-up. 😁 When you say small, is it 'do not even try' small, or it can work but with 'benefit' of reduced peak power?
Carb actually looks OK. Is a power jet too. But too small for a performance 250. It will run and ride, probably fine at low rpm.

When a carb is too small for an engine it struggles to give consistent results. Occasionally leans out. Lower acceleration. Possibly lower max power.

Depending on the port timing this may not matter. If it is kept lower for lazy gear shifts, the 28 will be OK. Medium aggressive port timing will need more carb though.
@ginch avatar
UTC

Veni, Vidi, Posti
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
 
Veni, Vidi, Posti
@ginch avatar
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
UTC quote
I know you well enough by now that you like to surprise, but can you point us towards your thinking on this? What's the plan?
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
I do like to surprise! πŸ˜‚ Admitedly, surprise my close ones. Apologies if it came accross through a forum writeup. 😁

Well, I was going to keep the scooter running without engine mods, until I get all the neccessary bits. Initially, I was gonna spend around 500eur every month, to keep the wallet (and my wife) happy. Two things working towards joint happyness plan was a purchase of SIP Primo service, and monthly SIP discount voucher.

A few things happened unexpectedly though.

Firstly, I'm at work, instead of at home (in the middle of freakin' nowhere right now), so no work on the Frankendrak project whatsoever. Below is explained why.

Secondly, the rotary pad and crank have kissed with help of, what looks to be a small washer. I see no point in taking the engine apart to replace the crappy gearbox bits, and run the damaged crank/pad combo afterwards. So new crank has got to come in, along with new cylinder and reed block.

Thirdly, the black discount period decided to speed things up a bit for me, if I opt to use the associated budget relief. But it entails doubling the expenditure. Ok, I'll survive the beating πŸ˜‚ but I need to hasten some decisions. Mainly, the choice of crank, cylinder and reed.

Which is why I suddenly started posting, after a month of silence. I've been lurking while at work, but had nothing to post really. Took a change in role, and found myself in an unknown territory, using personal time to familiarize with the new responsibilities. But, end is near, so I'm spritually back. And with that new discoveries, mostly illuminating my choices. Their value, rather. πŸ˜‚

I'm pretty much set on Explorer and Uncle Tom by now. I'd love the m244, but not at 750eur. I've reached out to my welder, and he said "I've done worse, no problem". And then he went on to critize the quality of welding, seen on the crankase, in the pic which Ginch shared. πŸ˜‚ Sorry Ginch, I had to illustrate the goal. But I'm quite happy with the feeling of confidence the welder conveyed. So that's is more or less a done deal.

But then, I'm not so sure about the choice of a carb any more. I was certain that 28 will suffice for the power goals. But in reality I don't have enough experience, so I rely on you lot. It's probably a good moment to show some appreciation. πŸ€” Thank you guys, I do appreciate your wisdom indeed. 🀝

So if I have to go bigger than 28, then I may as well do it now, before I get a reed manifold, which may end up being too small down the line. I'd much rather get the manifold once than twice, obviously. 😁 If I had to, I'd even get the bigger manifold to use with carb I already have, than smaller manifold to use with future carb. I hope I'm explaining this correctly.

That's what's cooking at the moment. Aesthetical mods to my Vespa will come later, and I'm not giving it much attention today.
Middle of freaking' nowhere I tell ya πŸ˜΅β€πŸ’«
Middle of freaking' nowhere I tell ya πŸ˜΅β€πŸ’«
@ginch avatar
UTC

Veni, Vidi, Posti
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
 
Veni, Vidi, Posti
@ginch avatar
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
UTC quote
Yeah I figured you worked remotely, but not in the manner we are all used to now.

The welded case was an example rather than something precious to me so no offense recorded!

If you use the MRP reed block, they have a variety of intakes that will fit the block. So you can get the block (think they are all designed to take rd350 reeds) and then get the intake to fit your carb. Here's some of the options, looks different on my phone but you can sort by size or fitment on pc.

https://www.mrp-racing.de/?jtl_token=3c6d8ac7e5abbcc31b8224b4a208de7158a8d3f6cbec4fdd0b8adfd9dea001c2&qs=Reed+valve&search=

So you don't need to buy much twice.

Will you get the most out of your 244 with a 28mm carb? No.
I run a 30mm carb on my 252 and it runs really well. I have a 35mm pwk airstriker on the shelf, one day I'll do an upgrade and try it out but I'm very happy with it right now.

I'm not sure how much you can open up the rotary valve on a short vs long as I've never compared them side by side. I guess the stud holes are all in the same location but don't know about that either.
I can only assume that by the time you've finished opening it up there won't be that much difference between them?

Edit: Duh. The difference is shown on the MRP site, pic added.
Forum member supplied image with no explanatory text
Forum member supplied image with no explanatory text
Forum member supplied image with no explanatory text
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Thanks Ginch, a photo really does go a long way, especially in this case. Longer vs shorter sealing surface is not insignificant, but also not a significant factor. I could have the area fortified with welding to allow for a larger intake port cross section.

As I am researching the larger PWKs now, I'm under the impression that the jet kit I have purchased actually does not fit the carb. I now think that what I have purchased may be the "mini" style body, in which case the full size jets don't fit. If true, that would suggest that I can't use the 28 even if it was a perfect fit for the project goals. πŸ˜’ Information overload, is what I'm feeling right now. Gotta look at this another day, with a fresh mind. πŸ€¦πŸ»β€β™‚οΈ

Jack221: Power jet is that doohickey connected to the float chamber via a hose? Should I be aiming to have it on a larger carb too? πŸ€” My heart is set on PWKs, no interesso in Dell'orto stuff, too much hassle in the days of working on Moto Guzzi's. 🀌🏻🀌🏻🀌🏻
UTC

Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
 
Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
UTC quote
Yes, the tube thing. Looks like there isn't a jet fitted in it. Having a power jet and not using it is an option. Easy to close off. Unlikely you'll need it though.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Ok, I no longer think that the carb I have is a mini style. Must have been tired last night when I came to that conclusion. So that means I can still try to use the 28 with the jet kit I have, although I'm considering just passing it on to a new owner.

Ginch is happy with a 30, chandlerman suggests up to 34, and jack221 up to 39mm. Basically anything in between should work, depending on timing and power production goals.

At this point, I think I'll stick to PWK clones. Any known good clones you guys are aware of?

Cheers
@ginch avatar
UTC

Veni, Vidi, Posti
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
 
Veni, Vidi, Posti
@ginch avatar
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
UTC quote
If that case intake hole is any bigger than just big enough to clear the size of a fully open reed, I reckon it's probably too big. If you feel you want to increase crankcase volume just use a packer.
Oh and I notice in the listings that SIP are saying the reed block fits a VF4 now. Wouldn't be the first time SIP were wrong but it would be nice if you had that option.

I just checked the carbs I have here. The PWK35 has a needle length of 65mm, and the PE28 (apparently uses the same needle as PWK28/30) needle length is about 56mm. That should tell you for sure.

I know chandlerman is using a knockoff on at least one of his, thought I had it bookmarked but typically can't find it now. Edit: found it, the brand is Nibbi. CM had some needle length issues with his according to a post I found but he'll be best to advise.
https://nibbiracing.com/en-au/collections/pwk-carburetor

I have a friend who used to run a Malossi MHR 221, reed intake, expansion exhaust etc. Had ride of it once some years ago and it was a bit scary. Anyway he had a PWK38 on there. Every year we do a 1000km in two days ride. The 3 guys he rode with were mildly tuned at best, he told me they got upset with him because every time they filled up he only used 1/2 to 2/3 of what they did. Just an interesting story.
Last year he tried to convince me to go to a SmartCarb, everything about it sounds great except for the price.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Ginch wrote:
...If you feel you want to increase crankcase volume just use a packer...
Actually, my only concern is for intake port not to be the bottleneck of the induction system. I think the carb should be the primary restriction in the intake tract, if at all possible.
Ginch wrote:
I just checked the carbs I have here. The PWK35 has a needle length of 65mm, and the PE28 (apparently uses the same needle as PWK28/30) needle length is about 56mm. That should tell you for sure.
I'll be home in about 5 days, so I'll measure what I have. Thanks.
Ginch wrote:
...brand is Nibbi. CM had some needle length issues with his according to a post I found but he'll be best to...
I ran into Nibbi when I was looking for ways to jet a PWK. Seemed like a good clone, from what I could see in the video. Prices are an incentive to purchase, that's for sure. Let's wait for chandlerman to send a word.
Ginch wrote:
...and it was a bit scary. Anyway he had a PWK38 on there. Every year we do a 1000km in two days ride. The 3 guys he rode with were mildly tuned at best, he told me they got upset with him because every time they filled up he only used 1/2 to 2/3 of what they did. Just an interesting story.
Scary in which way? Unpredictable? Sounds fun! πŸ˜‚

I've ridden many machines over the years, and I have this requirement for my machine, be it a truck, car or a bike, it needs to have plenty of reserve power. It needn't be the fastest machine in the world, but I need to have power on tap, when I feel traffic situation demands it. I see this as a safety feature.
On a flip side, I want also to be able to cruise peacefully, and appreciate the economical aspect of the same machine. Some well say, well that's not possible. And I would agree to a point. It wasn't possible for the most of time, but advancements in fuel control make it very possible nowadays. I'm ecstatic to see it's possible in a Vespa too. πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‘πŸ»
Ginch wrote:
Last year he tried to convince me to go to a SmartCarb, everything about it sounds great except for the price.
When I started lurking a few years back, I made a choice that when I get a Vespa, and start to modify it, I'll put in a smartcarb and be done with it. But yeah, price is a deterrent, and it has gone slightly up since when I first became aware of its existence.
What about Lectron? That's also a... what's the expression... a measuring carb? πŸ€”πŸ€·πŸ»β€β™‚οΈ
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Is it reasonable to sustain up to 35hp (medium spring stiffness on the VMC Ergal clutch) on a keyed/conical shaft?
@chandlerman avatar
UTC

Innovator
63 GL, 62 VBB, 05 Stella, 66 Smallstate, 66 Lammy S3, 63 Lammy S3 Riverside
Joined: UTC
Posts: 13341
Location: Nashville

400 Days Since Last Explosion
 
Innovator
@chandlerman avatar
63 GL, 62 VBB, 05 Stella, 66 Smallstate, 66 Lammy S3, 63 Lammy S3 Riverside
Joined: UTC
Posts: 13341
Location: Nashville

400 Days Since Last Explosion
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
I ran into Nibbi when I was looking for ways to jet a PWK. Seemed like a good clone, from what I could see in the video. Prices are an incentive to purchase, that's for sure. Let's wait for chandlerman to send a word.
Note: I'm going to use a bunch of PWK-specific terms here. You should learn them, because you're going to need to know them if you run these carbs.

I've got a couple of Nibbi's (a 32 on my GL and now a 30 on my Riverside) now and they're good for the price. Nice CNC work and good overall performance. The powerjet is a nice addition, but it did force me to change up my carb adjusting game a little.

One thing I don't like about the powerjet is that there can be a bit of lag between when you snap the throttle and you get proper fuel delivery. I saw where Some (Even More Random Than Me) Guy On The Internet installed little tiny check valves into his to prevent the backflow and reduce that lag. I couldn't find the teeny-tiny check valves that would require, so I just live with it.

The challenge I've run into with PWK's, especially the 34, is that they're bastard sizes in terms of needles. They use needles that are really intended for a PWK 28 or 30, so you will find yourself with a lot of situations where you're on 4th or 5th clip of the L length (longest L1 (length)) and have to live with rich or lean spots as a result.

You're also going to be unable to find alternate slides for the 32 or 34, so no richer slides and you're Dremeling if you need to go leaner with the slide (which you're more likely to do since you can't get the diameters you need in the L length).

I've also run Polini PWK's 34's for several years and they have similar tuning challenges regarding L1, but don't have the powerjet to contend with. They carbs themselves a decent quality, though.

Finally, for comparison I've also run Genuine Keihin's. My first PWK was a PWK 28 and I've never thought it was worth a damn. Cheaping out on stuff like a nylon idle adjuster screw, so you you either replace it with a brass one or get ready for it to snap off and force you to drill it out and hope you don't ruin the threads in the carb body.

I also have a PWK 36 in my smallie and it uses different needles which are properly sized for the diameter. Once dialed in, it was rock solid.

Whatever you do, don't cheap out on jets and needles. Find a quality source and get ready to drop some cash, at least here in the states. Jets and needles used to be like $5 and $10 each. I bought some this summer and they were more like $12 and $20. I don't know how much of that is tariffs fucking me over and how much is just price inflation, but by the time you get through the jetting process, you're going to have a pretty good collection. And don't forget about shipping and wait time, meaning you're going to find yourself ordering three or four potential needles instead of just one as a result.
Rikko wrote:
Is it reasonable to sustain up to 35hp (medium spring stiffness on the VMC Ergal clutch) on a keyed/conical shaft?
Google says 35 HP with the hard springs, but the largeframe clutch isn't a conical shaft.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Firstly, thanks dude for sharing this knowledge! That superstar supporter award is well deseved. πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‘πŸ»
chandlerman wrote:
...32 on my GL...
Do you remember the jet sizes? Just to give me an idea on where to start.
chandlerman wrote:
...Some (Even More Random Than Me) Guy On The Internet installed little tiny check valves into his to prevent the backflow and reduce that lag. I couldn't find the teeny-tiny check valves that would require, so I just live with it.
I'll scavange the web to find them 😁
chandlerman wrote:
The challenge I've run into with PWK's, especially the 34, is that they're bastard sizes in terms of needles. They use needles that are really intended for a PWK 28 or 30...
I have a full kit of needles for 28. So they could go up to 34 then. Good to know.
chandlerman wrote:
You're also going to be unable to find alternate slides for the 32 or 34...
I'm not very familiar with the subject. Why would you want to replace a slide? What range is tuned with a slide? Is it like on the SI carburettors?
chandlerman wrote:
I also have a PWK 36 in my smallie and it uses different needles which are properly sized for the diameter. Once dialed in, it was rock solid.

Whatever you do, don't cheap out on jets and needles. Find a quality source and get ready to drop some cash...
I share your opinion. Ideally I would get in the ballpark with crappy jets, and then buy good stuff in similar sizes.
chandlerman wrote:
Google says 35 HP with the hard springs, but the largeframe clutch isn't a conical shaft.
I already have the VMC clutch, it states that their spring setup is 20hp on the soft, 35 on the medium and 45 on hard springs. But that's not an issue, I have all springs in the kit, I can mix'n'match. My primary concern is the shaft, and how worried should I be transfering about 30HP through the keyed interface. I thought these were conical. πŸ€” Well, clutch is keyed for sure, possibly I just didn't pay attention. Maybe I mixed it up with the flywheel side of the shaft... πŸ™„
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
I'll scavange the web to find them 😁
From a company that also makes aftermarket power jets: https://thunderproducts.com/product/one-way-check-valve/
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
...Maybe I mixed it up with the flywheel side of the shaft... πŸ™„
Duh πŸ€¦πŸ»β€β™‚οΈ Now when i look at the photo, I knew it was a straight shaft, what was I thinking?
Definitely not conical on the clutch side.
Definitely not conical on the clutch side.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
Duh πŸ€¦πŸ»β€β™‚οΈ Now when i look at the photo, I knew it was a straight shaft, what was I thinking?
Ok, let me rephrase my previous question about power transfer.

Would you rather have a:
- woodroof keyed crank with a race-conrod
- splined shaft crank with a sport-conrod

Race vs Sport classification comes from SIP description of their product. Just to reiterate, my power goals are up to 30hp on this build.

To explain the reasoning, when I obtained the VMC Ergal clutch, plan was to use it on a stock engine until project progresses to more power. So I ordered the one with a woodroof interface. Since, a damage was discovered on the rotary pad, and therefore the Vespa won't be used in the stock form any longer. Realistically, it would have been better if the splined clutch was ordered to begin with. Unfrotunately, not the case.

So today, and by today I mean before the end of the month in CET zone, I need to choose between the two choices above. Cost difference should compensate a lot for a purchase of a splined gear for the VMC clutch I already own. 50eur less towards the sport version of the crank, and then 70eur more (+shipping) towards a splined clutch baseplate.

As always, TIA
SIP Uncle Tom bell-shaped, splined crank with sport-conrod
SIP Uncle Tom bell-shaped, splined crank with sport-conrod
VMC Ergal clutch splined baseplate
VMC Ergal clutch splined baseplate
@gravelrash2004 avatar
UTC

Molto Verboso
P Series / LML / Motovespa
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1911
Location: UK
 
Molto Verboso
@gravelrash2004 avatar
P Series / LML / Motovespa
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1911
Location: UK
UTC quote
If money is not a consiseratio

VMC clutch on a spliced shaft

Spliced shaft and massless clutch
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Gravelrash2004 wrote:
If money is not an option...
Well that's the thing, I'm as stretched as I can be at the moment, with very little wiggle room. I'm literally choosing sellers right now who will offer free shipping to cut this month's budget overspend. πŸ˜‚ Which, for me is SIP, cause of the Primo subscription.

What's your take on the connecting rod choice?
@gravelrash2004 avatar
UTC

Molto Verboso
P Series / LML / Motovespa
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1911
Location: UK
 
Molto Verboso
@gravelrash2004 avatar
P Series / LML / Motovespa
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1911
Location: UK
UTC quote
Conrod when it says "sport" or "race" usually refers to the size of the main conrod bearing at the Web end.

It also could typically denotes some or all of the following

Larger cutouts for lubrication
Larger bearing itself
Cage material
Polished and knife edged conrod (old school)

To make a proper Informed choice one would need to understand these.
UTC

Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
 
Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
UTC quote
Woodruff key is fine. More than sufficient for your build.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Gravelrash2004 wrote:
...To make a proper Informed choice one would need to understand these.
Understood and agreed. Unfortunately, SIP is somewhat cryptic about it, description of both cranks is largely generic. Thanks nevertheless.
Jack221 wrote:
Woodruff key is fine. More than sufficient for your build.
Cheers Jack221, woodroof crank it is then. πŸ₯³
@roland87 avatar
UTC

Molto Verboso
'13 LML Star 200, '81 50 Special, '81 P 150 X, '89 PK 50 Nuova, '84 PK 50 S, '82 PK 50 S
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1866
Location: Ukraine. Kyiv.
 
Molto Verboso
@roland87 avatar
'13 LML Star 200, '81 50 Special, '81 P 150 X, '89 PK 50 Nuova, '84 PK 50 S, '82 PK 50 S
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1866
Location: Ukraine. Kyiv.
UTC quote
For your peace of mind, you can use high quality Crimaz or DRT woodruff keys.
UTC

Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
 
Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
UTC quote
roland87 wrote:
For your peace of mind, you can use high quality Crimaz or DRT woodruff keys.
Here's a point of discussion. A long time ago I fitted a drt key in new crank. Flywheel came loose and the key remained in perfect condition. Crank and flywheel keyways were both damaged. I now prefer the key to be softer and the sacrificial part.
@roland87 avatar
UTC

Molto Verboso
'13 LML Star 200, '81 50 Special, '81 P 150 X, '89 PK 50 Nuova, '84 PK 50 S, '82 PK 50 S
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1866
Location: Ukraine. Kyiv.
 
Molto Verboso
@roland87 avatar
'13 LML Star 200, '81 50 Special, '81 P 150 X, '89 PK 50 Nuova, '84 PK 50 S, '82 PK 50 S
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1866
Location: Ukraine. Kyiv.
UTC quote
Jack221 wrote:
Here's a point of discussion. A long time ago I fitted a drt key in new crank. Flywheel came loose and the key remained in perfect condition. Crank and flywheel keyways were both damaged. I now prefer the key to be softer and the sacrificial part.
I tried few times DRT, Crimaz and Polini. Never had problems but maybe engines haven't enough power to ruin keyways...
Also Crimaz keys need to file down to fit.
When I saw Erich(EGIG) use cheap keys even on his 180cc engines I also don't care about this famous keys.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Jack221 wrote:
...I now prefer the key to be softer and the sacrificial part.
Most certainly agreed. Especially if a crank is a 400€ piece. 😁

Which is in a way an announcement that I have but the bullet. One VMC Explorer cylinder kit and one SIP Performance Uncle Tom bell shaped crankshaft are being prepared and shipped next working day. πŸ‘πŸ»

Edit: Prices:

Discount consumed and budget survived!
You'll notice that I don't mention the manifold, carb or reed. That's cause I didn't place an order. Interestingly enough, shopping on MRP website directly is more economical without than on SIP with the discount. So some bits will be ordered next month. πŸ‘πŸ»
⚠️ Last edited by Rikko on UTC; edited 1 time
@ginch avatar
UTC

Veni, Vidi, Posti
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
 
Veni, Vidi, Posti
@ginch avatar
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
UTC quote
Jack's crank story is a good one. I sheared a key on my Uncle Tom (hit a big bump and knocked it into third at fairly high speed), after replacement was able to keep going.
I do wonder if the crank was splined, what would have happened? Twisted the crank maybe?

The difference between the two rods is obvious visually, but is there an actual benefit to the shiny rod? I seem to recall that Worb 5 used to polish the outer surfaces of their rods in some instances. You would have to think that the power difference would be tiny?

Great to hear that the bullet has been chewed upon! Get your welder to take plenty of photos of the process (and his superior welding of course).

Possibly it would be worthwhile beefing up the primary shaft area next to the clutch while he's at it? Jack?
@safis avatar
UTC

Veni, Vidi, Posti
1979 P150X, 1983 P200E, 1987 PK125XL Elestart, 1988 T5, 1995 PX200E
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5588
Location: Veria, Greece
 
Veni, Vidi, Posti
@safis avatar
1979 P150X, 1983 P200E, 1987 PK125XL Elestart, 1988 T5, 1995 PX200E
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5588
Location: Veria, Greece
UTC quote
The polished rod is forged. Both rods are great though since Primatist is a top manufacturer…
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Ginch wrote:
Jack's crank story is a good one. I sheared a key on my Uncle Tom (hit a big bump and knocked it into third at fairly high speed), after replacement was able to keep going.
I do wonder if the crank was splined, what would have happened? Twisted the crank maybe?
I suddenly feel much more relieved for ordering a keyed shaft πŸ˜‚
Ginch wrote:
The difference between the two rods is obvious visually, but is there an actual benefit to the shiny rod? I seem to recall that Worb 5 used to polish the outer surfaces of their rods in some instances. You would have to think that the power difference would be tiny?
I thought the difference is mostly associated with transfer of forces between piston and crank. Never gave it a thought about power increase due to reduced drag.
Ginch wrote:
Great to hear that the bullet has been chewed upon! Get your welder to take plenty of photos of the process (and his superior welding of course).
I'll do my best. πŸ˜‚ As a customary of good business back home, we don't discuss price over a phone. So I'm yet to sit down with him and see who's got the upper hand.
Ginch wrote:
Possibly it would be worthwhile beefing up the primary shaft area next to the clutch while he's at it? Jack?
Gravelrash2004 mentioned turning down the christmas tree, and welding up the case. I've had some ideas since, I'll see it up close when I get home. I'll explain in detail once I know more myself.
UTC

Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
 
Jet Eye Master
PX221 MHR heavily tuned, PX200 O tuned, PX181 M1XL tuned, PX166 tuned a quite bit and some motorbikes
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5505
Location: London UK
UTC quote
While at the welders, it would be just one extra job to install the SaFiS reinforcement piece.
However, if you're not going to use it as a stunt bike, it will likely be fine. Saying that, once over 30bhp it is very difficult to not do the occasional wheelie or wheel spin.
Going back to rotary (Post 2445483)
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Jack221 wrote:
While at the welders, it would be just one extra job to install the SaFiS reinforcement piece.
However, if you're not going to use it as a stunt bike, it will likely be fine. Saying that, once over 30bhp it is very difficult to not do the occasional wheelie or wheel spin.
Going back to rotary (Post 2445483)
Occasional wheelies will be had, I'm certain. If it happened on my stock scoot, for sure it'll happen when it's about 3-4x more powerful. πŸ˜‚

Is this SaFiS' plate meant to reinforce the same area Gravelrash2004 was discussing, a.k.a. the thin-walled opening for the Christmas tree? Interesting take, if so, stiffens the inside to prevent overall flex. πŸ€” I assume the hole in the plate is just for output shaft to pass through.

External inline image provided by member with no explanatory text
@safis avatar
UTC

Veni, Vidi, Posti
1979 P150X, 1983 P200E, 1987 PK125XL Elestart, 1988 T5, 1995 PX200E
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5588
Location: Veria, Greece
 
Veni, Vidi, Posti
@safis avatar
1979 P150X, 1983 P200E, 1987 PK125XL Elestart, 1988 T5, 1995 PX200E
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5588
Location: Veria, Greece
UTC quote
These are from an older set of cases that I converted to reeds before going back to rotary and the Malossi cases. That thread is dead because I used tinypic for the pics. Here's the reinforcements I did to them...
Primary area
Primary area
Gearbox plate
Gearbox plate
Cylinder base
Cylinder base
@gravelrash2004 avatar
UTC

Molto Verboso
P Series / LML / Motovespa
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1911
Location: UK
 
Molto Verboso
@gravelrash2004 avatar
P Series / LML / Motovespa
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1911
Location: UK
UTC quote
SaFiS wrote:
These are from an older set of cases that I converted to reeds before going back to rotary and the Malossi cases. That thread is dead because I used tinypic for the pics. Here's the reinforcements I did to them...
That is some awesome work... combine that with the turned down Xmas tree sbaft . Or one from a PX80 and shrink the size of the hole it slides into to match. 2mm different is all you need to bring you online with a malossi case thickness in tbat area

Then it shoukd be pretty bullet proof
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
SaFiS wrote:
These are from an older set of cases that I converted to reeds before going back to rotary and the Malossi cases. That thread is dead because I used tinypic for the pics. Here's the reinforcements I did to them...
What you've done, as per first photo, is almost exactly what I had in mind. πŸ˜‚ All I can say is that one can be very pleased to receive reassurement that one's not crazy. 😁

Re. turning down the tree, that's feasible too. I would then insert a sleeve inside the existing hole, to reduce its diameter (secured with a line of weld). Sort of an effort to maintain concentricity. And then it can be reamed out to final size.
@ginch avatar
UTC

Veni, Vidi, Posti
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
 
Veni, Vidi, Posti
@ginch avatar
74 Super, 75 Super, PX project, LML off-roader and '66 Blue Badge Smallframe
Joined: UTC
Posts: 10478
Location: Ballarat VIC, Australia
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
Re. turning down the tree, that's feasible too. I would then insert a sleeve inside the existing hole, to reduce its diameter (secured with a line of weld). Sort of an effort to maintain concentricity. And then it can be reamed out to final size.
I saw a Posch Performance video where the case was cracked through the clutch cover opening. He opened the hole to 25mm with a hole saw, then inserted a self-made bush from 25mm round stock. I think (from memory, frustratingly I can't find the video ) that he said he felt it was better than new because the 25mm gave him plenty of weld area. He left the shaft at the normal diameter.

It doesn't always break there with powerful motors, but it is a known weak point.
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
Ginch wrote:
I saw a Posch Performance video where the case was cracked through the clutch cover opening. He opened the hole to 25mm with a hole saw, then inserted a self-made bush from 25mm round stock. I think (from memory, frustratingly I can't find the video ) that he said he felt it was better than new because the 25mm gave him plenty of weld area. He left the shaft at the normal diameter.

It doesn't always break there with powerful motors, but it is a known weak point.
Ok, I'm onto something then, good.
Begs the question though (until I find the video), 25mm slug surely protruded into the clutch space, yes? Should be easy to grind off though...
OP
@rikko avatar
UTC

Addicted
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
 
Addicted
@rikko avatar
LML Vespa 150N
Joined: UTC
Posts: 637
Location: at Sea
UTC quote
On another note. I have forgotten about the cylinder studs entirely. Facepalm emoticon

From what I see, Explorer should use stock PX200 studs. Anyone knows from first hand?
@chandlerman avatar
UTC

Innovator
63 GL, 62 VBB, 05 Stella, 66 Smallstate, 66 Lammy S3, 63 Lammy S3 Riverside
Joined: UTC
Posts: 13341
Location: Nashville

400 Days Since Last Explosion
 
Innovator
@chandlerman avatar
63 GL, 62 VBB, 05 Stella, 66 Smallstate, 66 Lammy S3, 63 Lammy S3 Riverside
Joined: UTC
Posts: 13341
Location: Nashville

400 Days Since Last Explosion
UTC quote
Rikko wrote:
On another note. I have forgotten about the cylinder studs entirely. Facepalm emoticon

From what I see, Explorer should use stock PX200 studs. Anyone knows from first hand?
Correct.

You're really taking this build off in an exotic direction. Usually people do stuff like this because A) They live somewhere that legally forbids putting a large block motor in a small block frame and they're skirting the laws; or B) They're just bored with doing things the "normal" ways.

A much better option would be something like a VMC or BGM 177 with a 110 rod (P200) 60mm crank and a ~6mm base spacer. Keep the cases more-or-less stock and work on learning how to build a fast motor. You can get you all the power you want if you build it right, but without all the welding, machining, non-standard configurations and pain that comes with going the exotic route.

Not that I'm not here to see how this plays out, but as someone who generally roots for people to succeed, I feel kind've obligated to say something. Unless you have a bunch more engine building experience than your questions lead me to believe, you're setting the difficulty mode to Nightmare here for questionable benefit.

Modern Vespa is the premier site for modern Vespa and Piaggio scooters. Vespa GTS300, GTS250, GTV, GT200, LX150, LXS, ET4, ET2, MP3, Fuoco, Elettrica and more.

Modern Vespa is made possible by our generous supporters.

Buy Me A Coffee
 

Shop on Amazon with Modern Vespa

Modern Vespa is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com


All Content Copyright 2005-2026 by Modern Vespa.
All Rights Reserved.


[ Time: 0.0388s ][ Queries: 4 (0.0307s) ][ live ][ 343 ][ ThingOne ]