Mesmer wrote:
FWIW I've had 2 exhaust bolts back out on their own (separate instances). Luckily both times the other 2 stayed in.
OP
|
UTC
quote
Mesmer wrote: FWIW I've had 2 exhaust bolts back out on their own (separate instances). Luckily both times the other 2 stayed in. |
OP
|
UTC
quote
windbreaker wrote: Ifixjets wrote: they had purchased an after market one for thier own scoot and realized it was junk As for the Act of God, I wouldn't go that far to call Jess God |
|
UTC
quote
jimc wrote: I'll ask Jess's question slightly differently, has anyone with a conventional OEM exhaust have these bolts unravel? |
Moderaptor
The Hornet (GT200, aka Love Bug) and 'Dimples' - a GTS 300
Joined: UTC
Posts: 44131 Location: Pleasant Hill, CA |
|
UTC
quote
jimc wrote: Except yours was welded as a one-piece... |
Moderaptor
The Hornet (GT200, aka Love Bug) and 'Dimples' - a GTS 300
Joined: UTC
Posts: 44131 Location: Pleasant Hill, CA |
UTC
quote
Without the graphite collar to allow the header pipe to move in relation to the exhaust itself, there must have been extra stresses and therefore strains - whether these are enough to help dislodge the bolts who knows.
|
|
UTC
quote
jimc wrote: Without the graphite collar to allow the header pipe to move in relation to the exhaust itself, there must have been extra stresses and therefore strains - whether these are enough to help dislodge the bolts who knows. And yes... Who knows... |
Addicted
2006 GT 200, 2007 BV 500
Joined: UTC
Posts: 922 Location: Campbell, California, USA, Earth |
UTC
quote
Now you guys made me go out and check my muffler!! It is OEM, has just over 16,000 miles, the Moto Amore "muffler bearing", a touch of antiseize on each OEM bolt and all 3 were tight as can be. The muffler has been removed and refitted probably 6 times so far, the last 5 times split at the muffler bearing location leaving the header pipe alone. That is a really strange phenomina. Does anyone know if the GT250 uses the same OEM bolt with a torque head as the GT200 OEM hex head bolt? Possibly a slight difference in the stainless steel thread? The mystery continues.
|
|
UTC
quote
the simplest answer
You all have come up with a variety of esoteric possibilities, but usually the simplest one is the right one:
Somebody took the bolts out ("screwing with him"?) |
Sir Frets-A-Lot
Vespa GT250ie/L, Honda Ruckus 50, Honda NT700V, Honda CB125
Joined: UTC
Posts: 11197 Location: Bee eff eee. |
UTC
quote
MichaelR wrote: Now you guys made me go out and check my muffler!! It is OEM, has just over 16,000 miles, the Moto Amore "muffler bearing", a touch of antiseize on each OEM bolt and all 3 were tight as can be. The muffler has been removed and refitted probably 6 times so far, the last 5 times split at the muffler bearing location leaving the header pipe alone. That is a really strange phenomina. Does anyone know if the GT250 uses the same OEM bolt with a torque head as the GT200 OEM hex head bolt? Possibly a slight difference in the stainless steel thread? The mystery continues. |
Addicted
2006 GT 200, 2007 BV 500
Joined: UTC
Posts: 922 Location: Campbell, California, USA, Earth |
UTC
quote
TheOZ: I know that one is a hex head and the other is a torx head but what I was asking is are the bolts the same other than the heads or are they a different size or length or different threads? It sort of makes one wonder why they changed to a torx head on the GT250. Just curious.
|
|
UTC
quote
O.K...thru all of these posts...I'm going to check out my exhaust and make sure it's secure...thanks!
But just one minute..the theft thing still sticks in my mind...two reasons: 1. Son had the lugs from his mags on his former car loosen when he got back to drive home...yes it was that noticeable! We called the police just to file a report and they told us the MO would be for one member of the theft team would walk by or just drive by and pick his target. Would then loosen the lugs...this was followed by someone coming by in a truck and quick as possible get it up on cinder blocks and load and drive off. 2. Related to #1...I've read that catalytic convertors are being ripped off and sold to scrap yards for the platinum found in the cc's. Per #1 and #2...that exhaust could have been destined to a scrap dealer per a theft ring that knows there's some value to either the exhaust or material therein. Then again...there are those darn exterrestrial types running around with nothing better to do... |
|
UTC
quote
mig wrote: It was me! I'm the friend in question. Annoyance and upcoming expense aside, my overwhelming thought is almost laughter... as in, "I can't BELIEVE this happened." The bike looks SO WEIRD missing everything to the right of the rear tire. Possibly the worst part of it was was being stuck for a while in the wind tunnel of the 101/280 split... I'm extremely fortunate that Jess came to my rescue (Jesscue?) but damn it was COLD! I don't think I've ever been happier to see someone... -mig!! |
Sir Frets-A-Lot
Vespa GT250ie/L, Honda Ruckus 50, Honda NT700V, Honda CB125
Joined: UTC
Posts: 11197 Location: Bee eff eee. |
UTC
quote
MichaelR wrote: TheOZ: I know that one is a hex head and the other is a torx head but what I was asking is are the bolts the same other than the heads or are they a different size or length or different threads? It sort of makes one wonder why they changed to a torx head on the GT250. Just curious. I think it's just the heads, if I recall correctly. And ironically, I believe the reason for it was to deter theft, or so goes the old wive's tale. |
|
UTC
quote
Mesmer wrote: FWIW I've had 2 exhaust bolts back out on their own upper bolt was snug. I had been hearing a rattling noise and (fortunately) found the cause before the muffler fell off. -David |
Veni, Vidi, Posti
63 GS160 MK1 / GT60 / Sean Wotherspoon
Joined: UTC
Posts: 6544 Location: Thousand Oaks |
UTC
quote
Re: Anyone ever had the exhaust fall completely off?
jess wrote: Last night, a friend of mine (riding a bike I sold him, my ex-red GTS250) called me from the side of the freeway, needing assistance. He was riding home from the Scoot to the Moon rally, and had put a lot of miles on during the day. Just a few miles from making it home, his exhaust had fallen completely off the bike, and was lying 100 yards back on the side of the road. The exhaust is demolished, bent and battered. The exhaust studs holding the exhaust header to the engine are snapped off. The lambda sensor is now a delta sensor, and the wires that lead to it are but little pins sticking out where the plug used to be. In order for this failure to occur, all three of the M8-sized bolts that carry all the weight of the exhaust would have to back themselves out. They were stainless steel bolts in an aluminum surface (the swingarm plate) and they had lock washers on them. I know, because I always put lock washers on them whenever installing an exhaust. Once those three bolts were out, of course, all the weight gets transferred to the exhaust studs at the engine head, and they can't take the weight of the exhaust bouncing around. I completely understand how those would have snapped (and that's going to be a bitch to fix). But the three bolts that carry all the weight mystify me. I just don't see how they could have backed out of the swingarm plate. And no, they're not sheared off. I checked. The holes are empty. So, I ask, incredulously: anyone else ever have your entire exhaust just up and fall off? Nobody got hurt, bike can be fixed, I say we are all good on this one. SDG |
UTC
Molto Verboso
1974 Rally 200
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1775 Location: Heading north on Forever Street |
|
Molto Verboso
1974 Rally 200
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1775 Location: Heading north on Forever Street |
UTC
quote
Once I had the steering wheel come off in my hands while traveling merrily along @ 70mph. This was on a Volvo 122 (pre-ol Yeller). Someone had forgotten to replace the locking washer. Thank goddess the wheels were in good alignment.
But that wasn't nearly as exciting as the time a Saab 96 V-4 engine burst into flames while, again, traveling merrily along @ 70 mph. Good times. \\osc Oh, right -- the exhaust fell off the Rally once. Does that count? |
UTC
Molto Verboso
1974 Rally 200
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1775 Location: Heading north on Forever Street |
|
Molto Verboso
1974 Rally 200
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1775 Location: Heading north on Forever Street |
UTC
quote
Why did half a Mod Rondel suddenly appear under my avatar? Sorry, didn't get the memo.
Do I have half good or bad karma? Only half 'cause I ride motos & scooters? Cause I mentioned a cage above??? Normally I am a Rondel-half-full kinda guy, but feel something is missing. |
|
UTC
quote
TB wrote: Mig...to you I give a lot of credit in keeping a postive attitude and yes, the worst part was getting inconvenience...however, you had a good buddy to help you out...I am fortunate to have the same. O.K. now with that being said...tell me is the noise level LOUD?...I mean can you go around and cozy up to those HD guys and join in? --I didn't ride over or hit anything like a pothole. --I noticed no noise before it happened, e.g. "something seems to be coming loose and rattling" type of noise. --The play-by-play, as best I can recall (it happened in a matter of a few seconds, and the adrenaline kicked in immediately): I was riding normally (probably about 70-75mph) at the end of the day. Had been riding all day and it was bliss. Suddenly I *felt* it... it wasn't like a loud "bang" but I suddenly *felt* something, as if something had just suddenly come off. I looked down and saw Some Big Black Chunk (later identified as the entire exhaust assembly) come off, and everything was suddenly rickety and LOUD. My immediate thought was actually that I'd blown the front tire, and so the high school driver's ed instinct kicked in: "try to let the car (scooter) come to a stop on its own while you gently steer it to the shoulder, applying the brake verrrrry gently." So that's what I did. I'm still baffled even after reading all the thoughts on this thread. I don't suspect foul play, but if it was, then HA HA, CHUMPS, I LIVE ON! |
|
UTC
quote
Just the entire muffler, not the whole system. Damn thing went bouncing down Highway 75 a few miles north of Pipestone, Minnesota.
It was 1966....and the bike was a 1955 Zundapp 250, a two stroke single. My dad bought it for me for $50 or $75, don't remember which. Sometimes it ran. A highway patrolman stopped on the shoulder behind me as I was trying to 'jerry-rig' the exhaust can back on the bike. Got my first ticket that day. I only had a 'learner's permit' and wasn't supposed to be driving or riding anything without a parent or licensed, adult driver along in the vehicle. Sorry for the long story, but you asked. |
|
UTC
quote
mig wrote: TB wrote: Mig...to you I give a lot of credit in keeping a postive attitude and yes, the worst part was getting inconvenience...however, you had a good buddy to help you out...I am fortunate to have the same. O.K. now with that being said...tell me is the noise level LOUD?...I mean can you go around and cozy up to those HD guys and join in? --I didn't ride over or hit anything like a pothole. --I noticed no noise before it happened, e.g. "something seems to be coming loose and rattling" type of noise. --The play-by-play, as best I can recall (it happened in a matter of a few seconds, and the adrenaline kicked in immediately): I was riding normally (probably about 70-75mph) at the end of the day. Had been riding all day and it was bliss. Suddenly I *felt* it... it wasn't like a loud "bang" but I suddenly *felt* something, as if something had just suddenly come off. I looked down and saw Some Big Black Chunk (later identified as the entire exhaust assembly) come off, and everything was suddenly rickety and LOUD. My immediate thought was actually that I'd blown the front tire, and so the high school driver's ed instinct kicked in: "try to let the car (scooter) come to a stop on its own while you gently steer it to the shoulder, applying the brake verrrrry gently." So that's what I did. I'm still baffled even after reading all the thoughts on this thread. I don't suspect foul play, but if it was, then HA HA, CHUMPS, I LIVE ON! |
|
UTC
quote
What direction did you park it in, in relation to the rotation of the planet?
Park it the wrong way for too long and the nuts will rotate themselves right off. It's a good plan to park it facing uphill so all the starts don't fall out too. /nods |
|
UTC
quote
Maybe I'm just lucky!
jimc wrote: Without the graphite collar to allow the header pipe to move in relation to the exhaust itself, there must have been extra stresses and therefore strains - whether these are enough to help dislodge the bolts who knows. |
|
UTC
quote
The same thing just happened to me not 20 minutes ago. Newish 2012 300 Super Sport with a bolt-on Leo Vince exhaust that was installed by the dealer. It had the run-in and one regular service under it's belt. Everything looked solid on the exhaust assembly the last time I washed it (a little over a week ago) and while I didn't check the bolts with a torque meter, I did make sure they weren't backing out or had any visual signs of stress. Nothing looked out of place when I gave the bike a walk-around pre-ride, either.
I was on Houston's 610 loop, doing a hair under 80, on a newly repaired piece of freeway (smooth - no bumps), when I started to change lanes to my right. I had passed an 18 wheeler and had just pulled into his lane about 20 meters in front of him when I thought he laid into his air horn. It was super loud and it sounded like he was 2 feet in back of me, not 20 meters. Either that or the Miata to my right had some sort of train horn installed and had decided to give me a sustained warning blast to make sure I didn't come into his lane. Either option was unnecessary and extremely annoying. A half second later, I realized what had actually happened. I got off the freeway at the next exit to verify and the entire pipe was gone. Two top bolts are completely missing and two bottom bolts are still holding the remaining tabs of the exhaust mounts. Not quite the same scenario, but still more than a little mysterious. I circled back to try to find my exhaust and clear it from the road, but it had already been pummeled and pushed over against the barrier on the inside lane. I'll try to go back for it tonight, when I just have to contend with sport bikes coming around the bend at 120 instead of a thick stream of traffic at 70. My Super now sounds like a combination MotoGP/trials bike. If loud pipes really do save lives, then I was the most saved individual on all of MV for the five minutes it took to complete my ride home.
Positive
|
OP
|
UTC
quote
bcanon wrote: I got off the freeway at the next exit to verify and the entire pipe was gone. Two top bolts are completely missing and two bottom bolts are still holding the remaining tabs of the exhaust mounts. Not quite the same scenario, but still more than a little mysterious. |
Ossessionato
2012 Kymco Like 200i (Sold), 2018 FLSL
Joined: UTC
Posts: 2757 Location: San Jose, CA |
UTC
quote
bcanon wrote: I got off the freeway at the next exit to verify and the entire pipe was gone. Two top bolts are completely missing and two bottom bolts are still holding the remaining tabs of the exhaust mounts. Not quite the same scenario, but still more than a little mysterious |
|
UTC
quote
No bell on this one, which could be half of the problem. The other part of the equation was me thinking, "I don't usually push 80 wearing jeans. I hope nothing bad happens..."
I knew there was a perfectly valid scientific explanation buried in there somewhere. |
UTC
Addicted
2012 Vespa GTS 250ie in Perseus Bronze 'Percy'
Joined: UTC
Posts: 693 Location: Pommie Banana Bender |
|
Addicted
2012 Vespa GTS 250ie in Perseus Bronze 'Percy'
Joined: UTC
Posts: 693 Location: Pommie Banana Bender |
UTC
quote
mig wrote: I'm still baffled even after reading all the thoughts on this thread. I don't suspect foul play, but if it was, then HA HA, CHUMPS, I LIVE ON! |
|
UTC
quote
Food for thought we are not allowed to use lock washers at my workplace and they define the purpose of lock washers as "assists the technician to remove hardware." We have to use lock nuts or thread-locker.
Sounds completely wrong, but all of our hardware comes with certifications of quality so I go with it. Plus if you think about it, a lock washer is only effective for the first couple turns anyway. I don't work for a hole in the wall shop either... 20 million people ride our roller coasters each year. |
OP
|
UTC
quote
stepho wrote: Plus if you think about it, a lock washer is only effective for the first couple turns anyway. Nylocks and thread lock are great, and I use them liberally. That said, I don't think we can reasonably disparage lock washers based on the idea that they fail to hold the fastener after they've already failed. The logic of that statement doesn't really pass muster. |
RIP
|
UTC
quote
I've had 3 screws that were holding my airbox disappear on a ride and it was dangling when i got to where i was going. Bad roads tho. Your roads seem better than ours. Where's Rod Sterling when you need him, besides dead. Hope you find the cause
|
OP
|
UTC
quote
judy wrote: I've had 3 screws that were holding my airbox disappear on a ride and it was dangling when i got to where i was going. Bad roads tho. Your roads seem better than ours. Where's Rod Sterling when you need him, besides dead. Hope you find the cause |
eeeee bip
BMW R1100RT The Problem Child Kymco Downtown 300 - I'm not the Uber Honda Cub - Scorched Earth Policy
Joined: UTC
Posts: 20924 Location: South East Great England of Britishland |
UTC
quote
claim
A friend had a Scorpion pipe fall off his GTS250.
Broke away from the rear mounting and fell away from the header. Nice. Bill x |
|
UTC
quote
jimc wrote: Ahem - the aluminium bits are at ambient temperature - or very close. Poorly insulated exhaust bolts might be a bit hotter. Guess which one expands... But the exhaust bolts are also well distanced from the heat, so I have no worries about heat differentials between bolts and their seatings. I'll ask Jess's question slightly differently, has anyone with a conventional OEM exhaust have these bolts unravel? |
Moderaptor
The Hornet (GT200, aka Love Bug) and 'Dimples' - a GTS 300
Joined: UTC
Posts: 44131 Location: Pleasant Hill, CA |
UTC
quote
That downpipe is completely cracked open - so there's no point hanging the disconnected exhaust at the side.
It'll be extremely loud - probably illegally so. |
UTC
Veni, Vidi, Posti
2019 GTS 300 HPE Supertech E3 62,000km
Joined: UTC
Posts: 6100 Location: Batmania aka Melbourne, Australia |
|
Veni, Vidi, Posti
2019 GTS 300 HPE Supertech E3 62,000km
Joined: UTC
Posts: 6100 Location: Batmania aka Melbourne, Australia |
OP
|
Modern Vespa is the premier site for modern Vespa and Piaggio scooters. Vespa GTS300, GTS250, GTV, GT200, LX150, LXS, ET4, ET2, MP3, Fuoco, Elettrica and more.