We had an '02 Forester that was paid off when my daughter wrecked it on an icy road. Went to look for another but that was just when the new model CR-V came out. I'm 6' tall and was never comfortable in the Forester. My knees always felt cramped and the seat always felt like it wasn't back far enough. Anyone in the back seat was in for the torture chamber leg-room wise if I had the seat all the way back.
The CR-V is far more comfortable, does almost as well in snow and ice and gets much better mileage. No matter how fast or slow I went on the freeway the Forester got 26 mpg. I've gotten as much as 32 in the CR-V
12