OP
Addicted
![]() 2006 GT 200, 2007 BV 500
Joined: UTC
Posts: 922 Location: Campbell, California, USA, Earth |
UTC
quote
I know motor oil has been talked about many many times. Shell Rotella synthetic 5W-40 is avialable around here at Kragens Auto supply for about $23 per GALLON which is a substancial savings. Has anyone had any problems or know of any reason not to use this oil in a GT200 or a BV500?
|
RIP
|
|
UTC
quote
judy wrote: I use it in mine. It's a good oil. |
Moderaptor
![]() The Hornet (GT200, aka Love Bug) and 'Dimples' - a GTS 300
Joined: UTC
Posts: 44675 Location: Pleasant Hill, CA |
|
UTC
quote
jimc wrote: It's absolutely fine. A good oil. |
|
Resident Gentleman
![]() --------2008 LX150-------- Sold
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5045 Location: Brady, TX |
UTC
quote
It's what I'm currently using. They sell it at Wal-Mart here by the quart. No problems so far.
|
Molto Verboso
![]() "Thread Killer Extraordinaire!"
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1303 Location: San Jose, CA, USA |
|
UTC
quote
I've been using it for about seven or eight years in BMW's and for the last year in Vespas. I buy it at Walmart by the gallon for around $19.
|
OP
Addicted
![]() 2006 GT 200, 2007 BV 500
Joined: UTC
Posts: 922 Location: Campbell, California, USA, Earth |
UTC
quote
Thanks all. I have only seen it by the gallon at Kragens, I probably should check Walmart. I maintain 3 different scooters so buying it by the gallon is probably the easiest way anyway.
|
|
UTC
quote
Check Winchester Auto Parts on Winchester Blvd. just north of Hamilton (on the right side as you go N.). Don't know if they have the stuff by the gallon, but I love their selection of "in-stock" goodies - esp. Seafoam.
|
|
UTC
quote
Rotella is for diesel engines, where the soot from the combustion process dirties up the oil almost instantly and it is not deemed important that diesel engines remain clean, therefore, the oil is not "designed" to keep the engine constantly clean as with an oil intended for gasoline engines. I would find an synthetic oil such as Total Quartz 9000, Elf Scooter Synthetic oil 5W-40.
Negative
|
|
UTC
quote
rbruce63 wrote: Rotella is for diesel engines, where the soot from the combustion process dirties up the oil almost instantly and it is not deemed important that diesel engines remain clean, therefore, the oil is not "designed" to keep the engine constantly clean as with an oil intended for gasoline engines. I would find an synthetic oil such as Total Quartz 9000, Elf Scooter Synthetic oil 5W-40. In addition the oil meets petrol engine specification, I can't remember if it's SL, SJ or SM - it certainly meets Piaggio specs. If you can get it cheap, use it. |
|
UTC
quote
"ROTELLA Products
Shell Rotella® T Synthetic SAE 5W-40 is a fully synthetic heavy-duty diesel and gasoline engine oil developed especially to meet the requirements of North ..." "Approvals and Recommendations API CI-4 PLUS, CI-4, CH-4, CG-4, CF-4, CF API SL, SJ, SH" www.shell.com |
|
UTC
quote
They (diesel engine oils) also have an additive called TBN to contrast sulphur which is not needed in gasoline engines and causes ash, a precondition to detonation.
If you look at specialized oils (or at least marketed for) motorbikes and scooters alike, these have zero ash. Even the technical chart for Total Quartz 9000 SAE 5W/40 vs Elf Scooter Oil Synthetic SAE 5W/40 shows differences, in viscosity at 100 °C and total ash! Of course Rotella has all the general qualifications for diesel and gasoline engine oils, but I would rather use an oil intended for scooter motors! I imagine that a single malt, red label, black label or blue label whisky is whisky after all, but it is different from its conception. That's my humble opinion! |
![]() UTC
Veni, Vidi, Posti
09 GTS (sold) 2014 NC700XD
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5016 Location: Charlotte, NC |
|
Veni, Vidi, Posti
![]() 09 GTS (sold) 2014 NC700XD
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5016 Location: Charlotte, NC |
UTC
quote
I stopped in at my local dealer a few weeks ago and he had Mobil 1 Turbo Diesel Truck oil. He said it was one of the best oils even for our Scooters. Found that interesting, but it does have 1% ash... so what would that mean???
|
Moderaptor
![]() The Hornet (GT200, aka Love Bug) and 'Dimples' - a GTS 300
Joined: UTC
Posts: 44675 Location: Pleasant Hill, CA |
|
UTC
quote
rbruce63 wrote: I imagine that a single malt, red label, black label or blue label whisky is whisky after all, but it is different from its conception. ![]() |
Moderaptor
![]() The Hornet (GT200, aka Love Bug) and 'Dimples' - a GTS 300
Joined: UTC
Posts: 44675 Location: Pleasant Hill, CA |
![]() UTC
Veni, Vidi, Posti
09 GTS (sold) 2014 NC700XD
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5016 Location: Charlotte, NC |
|
Veni, Vidi, Posti
![]() 09 GTS (sold) 2014 NC700XD
Joined: UTC
Posts: 5016 Location: Charlotte, NC |
UTC
quote
jimc wrote: The ash bit is bollocks. |
|
UTC
quote
I got for dad's 81st birthday single malt, should I've gotten, black or blue label?
I am going for ashless scooter oil from Libya sucked by Total/Elf or something similar, but hey I live in Costa Rica a free country! |
Molto Verboso
![]() "Thread Killer Extraordinaire!"
Joined: UTC
Posts: 1303 Location: San Jose, CA, USA |
UTC
quote
Don't Diesel engines also filter down to 1 micron or something? The soot gets filtered out anyhow. A scooter filter will filter out particles down to a size deemed by the manufacturer to be tolerable to that particular engine. Rotella exceeds the recommended oil's specs and can be had for $4-$5 a quart. For me, we have a winnah!
And for the record, Talisker 16 year is my malt of choice. |
![]() UTC
Enthusiast
2007 GTS 250ie Yellow, Buddy 125cc White
Joined: UTC
Posts: 51 Location: Portland, OR USA |
|
Enthusiast
![]() 2007 GTS 250ie Yellow, Buddy 125cc White
Joined: UTC
Posts: 51 Location: Portland, OR USA |
UTC
quote
I can't believe it; my first service on my 250ie at 625 miles; they use just standard 5-30 motor oil; nothing special for scooters over any other vehicle; just the number. Does that sound normal?
|
|
UTC
quote
In mine an air cooled scooter the 40 portion of the viscosity rating is very important because under the load that this engine is subjected the manufacturer might want a thicker oil to prevent, metal to metal contact in high stress/high temperature operation and to minimize oil consumption.
I would definitively replace it with a motor oil that meets or exceeds the manufacturer specifications, in this case a synthetic SAE 5W/40 with an API rating SM or better or according to your manual. If you are not inclined to do the service yourself, then you can buy and take it to your dealer to perform the service. |
![]() UTC
Veni, Vidi, Posti
2007 Vespa LX 190, 2011 LXV150ie
Joined: UTC
Posts: 8758 Location: Annapolis, MD, USA |
|
Veni, Vidi, Posti
![]() 2007 Vespa LX 190, 2011 LXV150ie
Joined: UTC
Posts: 8758 Location: Annapolis, MD, USA |
UTC
quote
UkuleleGenie wrote: I can't believe it; my first service on my 250ie at 625 miles; they use just standard 5-30 motor oil; nothing special for scooters over any other vehicle; just the number. Does that sound normal? |
|
UTC
quote
I trot out this every time. I hate doing it, too, but......
From lets talk OIL. Andrea wrote: NightWing wrote: Somewhere in the recent past, there was a thread that discussed Mobil 1 oil. There were reasons posted why Mobil 1 is not suitable for use in Vespa engines. I can't remember the details but maybe someone familiar with the thread can chime in. I know for a fact that some one who has used Mobil 1 in their Vespa will have their warranty claim refused by Piaggio if their engine blows. We had a guy that we'd never dealt with before bring a GTS with a blown engine to us. Piaggio was very interested because they apparently hadn't had an engine go like this before. They specifically asked which oil the customer had been using. The customer stated that he used Mobil 1 because he read it on a forum or in a magazine somewhere. Piaggio disallowed the the warranty claim because he hadn't used an oil with the properties specified in the manual and specifically stated that Mobil 1 contained too many anti friction additives and it wasn't designed for use in motorcycles. I don't know if the customer fought the warranty denial or how he got on if he did because he's never been back in contact with us We've been selling new Vespas since 2000 and this is the first time we've seen them deny a warranty claim, apart from batteries. Andrea "SAE 5W-40 Synthetic oil that exceed the require- ments of API SL, ACEA A3, JASO MA specifications" It's in your owners manual & the workshop manual. Do with it what you will. Harvey |
![]() UTC
Addicted
GTS250, P200E
Joined: UTC
Posts: 777 Location: Oshawa, Ontario, Canada |
|
|
UTC
quote
There seems to be more myth than truth available on the Internet about Mobil1 oils. The "too slippery for motorcycles" quote concerns any oil that is energy saving (see the donut on the back label) when used with a wet clutch. Vespas do not have a wet clutch. Incidentally, 5W-40 oils are not energy saving.
In North America where it is impossible to get the Piaggio-recommended brands of oil, the European car recommended 5W-40 synthetic oils are a very good substitute. These oils are designed for use in Mercedes, VW, BMW, and Volvo. Most carry the MS rating. Nobody ever destroyed an engine by using the wrong brand of oil, but don't use the wrong type... Cheers and good luck, Bob |
|
![]() UTC
Banned
29,000 miles on my atlantic pastel green 2007 GTS 250
Joined: UTC
Posts: 4332 Location: Utah Valley |
|
RIP
Banned
![]() 29,000 miles on my atlantic pastel green 2007 GTS 250
Joined: UTC
Posts: 4332 Location: Utah Valley |
UTC
quote
I used to use Amsoil for a while. Designed for motorcycles, they say.
I'm suspicious about the Rotella. It is way too cheap to be good. But I use it anyway now ...oh, and it IS energy saving. Look at my gas mileage! |
|
UTC
quote
Agip is available from their North American website or Motorsport West ( EDIT: Motorsport sells 1L sizes).
Repsol I've picked up from the local Honda motorcycle dealer. I've also bought Motul. They all have products that meet the full Piaggio specs. Harvey ⚠️ Last edited by Harvey on UTC; edited 3 times
|
![]() UTC
Enthusiast
2007 GTS 250ie Yellow, Buddy 125cc White
Joined: UTC
Posts: 51 Location: Portland, OR USA |
|
Enthusiast
![]() 2007 GTS 250ie Yellow, Buddy 125cc White
Joined: UTC
Posts: 51 Location: Portland, OR USA |
UTC
quote
Thanks for all these replies. It appears growing up having to change my own oil in vehicles (my dad and brothers taught me how-I'm the only girl in my 'circle' that ever did this) just might come in handy again now. I'm 3 months new at scootering & owning a Vespa and I've just ordered the tech manual, but any advice on accomplishing this and (every 3000 mi??) and helpful hints are SOOOOO appreciated. I'm still a little uncomfortable as I cannot sit flat-footed and always lean to the left when I stop; if it goes over (even just in the garage), I'd never be able to pick the thing up.
But, oh the ride is so very nice ('Been down just once, in my motorcycling class, on a different scooter. 'Don't want to repeat THAT) |
|
UTC
quote
Zwerski wrote: Don't Diesel engines also filter down to 1 micron or something? The soot gets filtered out anyhow. A scooter filter will filter out particles down to a size deemed by the manufacturer to be tolerable to that particular engine. Rotella exceeds the recommended oil's specs and can be had for $4-$5 a quart. For me, we have a winnah! And for the record, Talisker 16 year is my malt of choice. Wayne B ⚠️ Last edited by Wayne B on UTC; edited 1 time
|
|
UTC
quote
Bob Cowley wrote: In North America where it is impossible to get the Piaggio-recommended brands of oil, the European car recommended 5W-40 synthetic oils are a very good substitute. These oils are designed for use in Mercedes, VW, BMW, and Volvo. Most carry the MS rating. Cheers and good luck, Bob I could get it from my dealer too, they stock it. Just bought a case of the Coolant I guess you can't get in the US either. Wayne B |
|
UTC
quote
Use the diesel oil! I use it. It is DUEL rated AND EXCEEDS the spec requirements of the scooter PLUS it has lubricity additives that add an extra level of protection. Plus you don't get ripped off by investing $23.00 a quart for some oil made in Switzerland and it's not even as good.
It must be the marketing! |
|
UTC
quote
Wayne B wrote: I buy it by the case right from American Agip. http://tinyurl.com/mpve47 I could get it from my dealer too, they stock it. Just bought a case of the Coolant I guess you can't get in the US either. Wayne B Did you access their filter oil? |
![]() UTC
Addicted
GTS250, P200E
Joined: UTC
Posts: 777 Location: Oshawa, Ontario, Canada |
|
|
UTC
quote
Sorry Wayne et al. I should have said Canada instead of North America. I have never seen Agip City Hi Tek 4T or Selenia Hi Scooter 4 Tech here. The only scooter-specific oils here are 10W-40, and they are rare.
Cheers and thanks, Bob |
![]() UTC
Banned
29,000 miles on my atlantic pastel green 2007 GTS 250
Joined: UTC
Posts: 4332 Location: Utah Valley |
|
RIP
Banned
![]() 29,000 miles on my atlantic pastel green 2007 GTS 250
Joined: UTC
Posts: 4332 Location: Utah Valley |
UTC
quote
louisq wrote: Thanks for the link, but for some it's impractical to stock enough oil to last 10 years..... Besides, they are 12 single 1L bottles. You can always find a nook and a cranny here and there to hide another bottle. Just keep track, so you'll find them again |
|
UTC
quote
windbreaker wrote: C'mon, ride some more! And it isn't even all that expensive, just $37 a gallon. |
|
UTC
quote
Bob Cowley wrote: Sorry Wayne et al. I should have said Canada instead of North America. I have never seen Agip City Hi Tek 4T or Selenia Hi Scooter 4 Tech here. The only scooter-specific oils here are 10W-40, and they are rare. Cheers and thanks, Bob Wayne B |
|
UTC
quote
louisq wrote: Wayne B wrote: I buy it by the case right from American Agip. http://tinyurl.com/mpve47 I could get it from my dealer too, they stock it. Just bought a case of the Coolant I guess you can't get in the US either. Wayne B Did you access their filter oil? Wayne B |
Modern Vespa is the premier site for modern Vespa and Piaggio scooters. Vespa GTS300, GTS250, GTV, GT200, LX150, LXS, ET4, ET2, MP3, Fuoco, Elettrica and more.